Did a vaping cessation trial ask everyone about the same harms?
Find how the trial collected prompted and spontaneous reports, and see which comparisons its harms table can support.
No Vape · Updated

Locate the question that could produce the row
CONSORT Harms explains how a trial might gather information using a planned questionnaire, examination or instrument. It also describes methods such as recording events participants mention voluntarily. In the methods, identify which route was used for the table entry you are reading. Look for a definition, who performed the assessment and the point in the follow-up schedule when it occurred.
A question specifically naming a problem means people have a chance to answer it directly. An unsolicited reporting route relies on people deciding what to bring up during an encounter or through a channel the study provides. The two can complement each other, particularly when a study wants to capture an unexpected issue.
BMJ — CONSORT Harms working group: CONSORT Harms 2022 statement, explanation, and elaboration
Check whether the opportunity to report was comparable
In a fictional cessation trial, both groups are asked the same set of questions during a four-week interview. People in one group also have an ongoing contact through which they can bring up concerns. An entry from the scheduled interview and an entry from ongoing contact answer different questions about what was observed. If a summary combines them, check whether the paper reports them separately before comparing groups.
The reporting guideline asks authors to separate systematically and non-systematically assessed harms and specify collection details. Write a short comparison note for each group: what was asked, when, through which channel and how many participants were assessed. If you cannot find these details, leave the comparison provisional.
BMJ — CONSORT Harms working group: CONSORT Harms 2022 statement, explanation, and elaboration
Interpret a zero or blank using the table legend
A row with zero occurrences under a defined scheduled assessment should stay attached to that assessment and time window. An empty cell could indicate missing data, a result the investigators did not report, or another explanation defined in the legend. Check the footnotes before assuming a blank means nobody experienced the issue.
A complete reading can retain both observations and uncertainty. For example, the paper reports answers to a fixed question for both groups, while only one group also had a separate contact channel. That tells readers how the information was gathered. Deciding whether a treatment suits a person requires a different judgment about the full evidence and their circumstances.
BMJ — CONSORT Harms working group: CONSORT Harms 2022 statement, explanation, and elaboration
Sources and scope
Sources inform the guidance. The worksheets and examples are No Vape editorial suggestions, not tested treatments.
Written with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No clinical review is claimed. This guide covers practical planning, not individual medical treatment. How we research and write