Why people in the same quit-vaping text trial received different messages
Trace a participant-selected quit date to a content path within the assigned text program.
No Vape · Updated

Draw the program assignment first
Krishnan and colleagues evaluated automated and counselor-delivered support in a pilot. The methods describe assigned program conditions. Inside the automated program, the authors also describe different message sequences depending on whether someone set a quit date. The date path gave more attention to practical skills and coping, while the path without a date emphasized motivation. Keep both decisions on paper. The research assignment determines which program was offered. A participant’s action inside that program determines which automated content path applied. The latter is a branching rule within delivery, with its own source and timing.
Try a timeline with two people in the same assigned group
Imagine a fictional participant enters a date after a few prompts. Another participant in the same assigned program leaves that question unanswered. Their original assignment can remain the same even as their subsequent messages diverge. A later difference between these people would not isolate the effect of the message wording. Their readiness and how they engaged with the program could differ as well. If you see a report that says one person “received the intervention” and another “did not,” check whether it means different assignments or different participation within a single assignment. The fictional timeline does not claim that either person quit.
Ask which decision the results compare
For each result, write the comparison label and how people came to be in the two groups. Where the methods describe on-demand requests or automated date-based messages, use those details to describe program delivery. Leave the number of messages a particular person opened unresolved unless the paper directly measured it. The pilot’s content branches do not establish that choosing a date produces a specific result, that every text service uses the same design or that another app sends those messages. If the table simply says “quit-date group,” identify whether that label refers to what people selected during delivery, what the system sent, or an analyst’s grouping later on. Those labels can describe different people. A good summary can explain the branch in one sentence and retain the separate randomized comparison in another.
Sources and scope
Sources inform the guidance. The worksheets and examples are No Vape editorial suggestions, not tested treatments.
Written with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No clinical review is claimed. This guide covers practical planning, not individual medical treatment. How we research and write