Skip to content
No Vape

Does a vaping questionnaire ask about the right things?

Check content relevance, missing concepts and respondent understanding before accepting a questionnaire validation claim.

No Vape · Updated

Disposable vape resting on concrete
Illustrative image · Markus Winkler / Unsplash

Start with the experience the instrument claims to describe

A paper about vaping may use a questionnaire for an experience such as an urge, confidence or difficulty with a routine. First identify that target and the people and setting for which the questionnaire was developed. A familiar title is insufficient: a shortened form or revised wording may represent a different version.

COSMIN describes content validity using relevance, comprehensiveness and comprehensibility. Its original methodology distinguishes investigating the content with intended respondents from checking a numerical property afterward. We use these concepts for reading public claims, without rating a named questionnaire or offering a test to use on yourself.

COSMIN Initiative: COSMIN Manual Version2.0 — content validity

Ask three different questions of the development report

For relevance, ask why the included material belongs to the stated experience and context. For comprehensiveness, ask how researchers looked for important aspects that might be absent. For comprehensibility, ask how they checked whether intended respondents understood the wording and response task as intended. A report can provide evidence for one question while leaving another unresolved.

Do not infer that an expert panel heard the same things as participants, or that an easy-to-read sentence covers every important concern. Locate who supplied input and what they were asked. Keep a missing account marked unavailable instead of assuming either a good process or a bad one.

Try a fictional coverage map

Imagine an invented questionnaire advertised as a measure of planning difficulty. Every question concerns finding a quiet place, while the advertisement also implies coverage of arranging support and managing changing schedules. The reading problem is not whether quiet places matter. It is whether the claimed breadth matches the instrument and the evidence used to select its content.

Draw a small map with the claimed experience in the center and the reported content areas around it. Add a separate note for whose input informed the map. An unmentioned area becomes a question about the claim, not an instruction to add your own item or produce a new score. This illustration describes no actual questionnaire or research result.

Keep a narrow conclusion and an open question

A useful summary names the version, intended use, respondents involved and aspects of content that were examined. It can say that comprehension was explored while coverage evidence remains unclear. Avoid reducing the entire instrument to a single valid or invalid label based on your reading exercise. Formal measurement appraisal requires expertise and the full evidence.

Content coverage also differs from relationships with other questionnaires, repeatability and demonstrated intervention benefit. If a score is being used in your care, ask the responsible professional what it measures and how it is interpreted. Your ordinary trigger notes can remain in your own words; they do not need a psychometric certificate to help organize a practical conversation.

Sources and scope

Sources inform the guidance. The worksheets and examples are No Vape editorial suggestions, not tested treatments.

  1. COSMIN Initiative — COSMIN Manual Version2.0 — content validity
  2. No Vape — No Vape — app features and store links

Written with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No clinical review is claimed. This guide covers practical planning, not individual medical treatment. How we research and write