Who did what in a vaping paper? Read the contribution statement
Use the published contribution roles to attribute work without turning author order, one task or an outside title into a quality verdict.
No Vape · Updated

Find the statement attached to the exact paper
Use the published article or its linked contribution section rather than a promotional biography. Preserve the role wording and the version you read. An author list, an institutional affiliation and a contribution statement describe different relationships. If no detailed statement is supplied, do not construct one from the first or last position in the byline.
NISO's CRediT resource describes a taxonomy of contributor roles and says it is not intended to define authorship. It allows multiple roles for one contributor and shared roles among several contributors. This is an attribution framework, not a quality scoring system or an independent check that every declared task occurred as described.
Make a task-to-person map
Choose the task relevant to the public claim you are reading. Copy its role label, the named contributors and any stated degree of contribution. Leave absent details absent. A person listed for obtaining resources is not automatically the person who ran the analysis, while a person who contributed to several roles need not be the only person responsible for the final report.
In a fictional example, a story calls a quoted coauthor the sole designer of a quitting study. The paper's contribution statement attributes methodology to several people and data curation to another contributor. The reader can correct the sole-designer wording without deciding who deserves more credit. No real author dispute is being asserted.
Keep roles separate from identity and interests
An ORCID link can help disambiguate a person, and a funding statement can disclose relationships, but neither replaces the contribution statement. Conversely, a named role does not establish a professional credential or the absence of a relevant financial connection. Read each record for the question it actually answers.
Do not treat involvement in one vaping paper as proof that someone reviewed No Vape or another commercial app. The report must establish that specific relationship. Nor should the presence of an analysis role be repeated as independent verification of the results. A declared responsibility and an external appraisal are different pieces of information.
Attribute the work without deciding the result from the names
A concise reading note can say that the statement declares these tasks for these contributors and that methodological quality remains a separate question. When the statement does not answer a relevant factual question, use the paper's designated correspondence route rather than messaging people through personal profiles or asking for private employment records.
The map cannot resolve authorship disputes, certify compliance with a journal policy or assess clinical advice. Its useful output is accurate language about who is described as doing which work. You still need the actual methods, comparison, outcome and limitations to understand a quitting finding; an impressive role label does not supply missing evidence.
Sources and scope
Sources inform the guidance. The worksheets and examples are No Vape editorial suggestions, not tested treatments.
Written with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No clinical review is claimed. This guide covers practical planning, not individual medical treatment. How we research and write