A realist quitting review asks how context and mechanisms shape outcomes
Find the proposed program theory and supporting evidence rather than expecting every review to supply one pooled quit percentage.
No Vape · Updated

Identify the explanatory question
A review about support may ask why an arrangement works differently across settings, rather than how large its average effect is. Locate that question and the program theory: the explanation of how the arrangement is expected to operate. Do not infer the question simply because a review contains interviews or lacks a combined statistical estimate.
The original RAMESES publication-standards paper explains realist synthesis through relationships between context, mechanisms and outcomes. It describes testing and refining program theory against relevant evidence. We use that methodological orientation only, not a new quitting theory, a formal assessment of a review or a claim that a particular service works.
Separate the three parts of one explanation
Create spaces for context, mechanism and outcome, using the authors’ own definitions. A program activity or resource is not necessarily the mechanism they propose; locate the reasoning or process linked to the outcome. If the distinction is unclear, keep it as a question instead of drawing a confident arrow that the review does not support.
Imagine an invented review proposing that a flexible meeting arrangement matters differently depending on people’s scheduling constraints and how they understand the invitation. A reader would ask what evidence supports those connections and what contrasting accounts were considered. The scenario supplies no actual support result or validated intervention. It illustrates an explanatory claim whose parts need to remain visible.
Trace an inference rather than counting favorable papers
Read how the review moved from source material to a context-mechanism-outcome explanation. Several pieces of evidence may serve different roles; a background account, comparison result and participant interpretation are not automatically interchangeable confirmations. Keep a source’s role beside the inference it informs. A useful theoretical explanation still needs a transparent evidentiary route.
Look for reported contexts where the explanation did not fit or was refined. Do not turn every different outcome into a post hoc story of success. Likewise, do not assume that a realist review’s conclusion is a numerical effect estimate simply because the sources include quantitative research. A claim about when a mechanism operates asks a different synthesis question.
Decide what the explanation can inform
Your final note can state the proposed explanation, relevant context, supporting evidence and unresolved boundary. It may suggest a focused question about a service’s actual arrangements. Verify those arrangements directly; a review from another setting does not establish local availability, cost or an individual response. An explanation can inform discussion without selecting care on its own.
For treatment-related decisions, ask qualified professionals about the complete evidence. This page does not conduct a realist synthesis, validate a mechanism or recommend adapting clinical support. Its useful output is a traceable account of one explanatory proposition. That helps you understand the kind of knowledge a review offers while preserving the difference between theory refinement, measured comparative effects and a personal prediction.
Sources and scope
Sources inform the guidance. The worksheets and examples are No Vape editorial suggestions, not tested treatments.
Written with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No clinical review is claimed. This guide covers practical planning, not individual medical treatment. How we research and write