Skip to content
No Vape

Why 2018 and 2019 NHIS vaping estimates are hard to compare

Read the NHIS bridge experiment before treating the 2019 jump in adult vaping estimates as a change in behavior.

No Vape · Updated

Disposable vape resting on concrete
Illustrative image · Markus Winkler / Unsplash

The part of the interview that changed

Read page 26 of the NCHS evaluation. Both years asked about e-cigarette use, but the 2018 interview introduced the item with a description of electronic cigarettes. The 2019 instrument dropped that introduction and used wording that explicitly mentioned other electronic vaping products. Its current-use indicator represents adults who reported using the products every day or on some days. An apparently familiar chart label can hide changes in what respondents heard and how they understood it.

The report discusses a questionnaire redesign more broadly. The comparison cannot isolate the influence of a single changed phrase. Keep the narrower claim that question design likely contributed to the gap.

National Center for Health Statistics: Preliminary Evaluation of the Impact of the 2019 NHIS Questionnaire Redesign and Weighting Adjustments on Early Release Program Estimates

What the bridge comparison holds steady

The fourth quarter of 2018 gives the report a comparison within the same part of the calendar. NCHS compared its regular production estimate with a bridge estimate collected using the updated questionnaire. In a second comparison it used the 2019 full-year data with the old and new weighting approaches. The weighting approaches determine how much responding records contribute to the estimate.

Read those comparisons in sequence. The bridge comparison asks whether estimates differ when the instrument changes. The second asks whether applying new weights to the 2019 data substantially changes the result. For this indicator the authors found likely evidence of a questionnaire effect and little evidence of a substantial weighting effect. This finding belongs to the methods and dates of that preliminary evaluation.

National Center for Health Statistics: Preliminary Evaluation of the Impact of the 2019 NHIS Questionnaire Redesign and Weighting Adjustments on Early Release Program Estimates

How to describe the chart in your own words

Imagine someone shares a slide with two bars and the caption “More adults started vaping between 2018 and 2019.” Write three lines before repeating it. The estimates come from different years. The questionnaire changed at that boundary. The NCHS bridge analysis leaves the change in actual behavior unresolved. Those lines identify both the observation and the remaining question.

If you build a slide, mark the redesign beside the year break or show the two estimates as separately labeled points. A reader should be able to tell which values were observed under each design and which comparison was conducted specifically to assess the design change. Keep the source date beside the methodological note so readers can find the original evaluation.

Sources and scope

Sources inform the guidance. The worksheets and examples are No Vape editorial suggestions, not tested treatments.

  1. National Center for Health Statistics — Preliminary Evaluation of the Impact of the 2019 NHIS Questionnaire Redesign and Weighting Adjustments on Early Release Program Estimates
  2. No Vape — No Vape — app features and store links

Written with AI assistance and checked against the cited sources. No clinical review is claimed. This guide covers practical planning, not individual medical treatment. How we research and write